One of my childhood memories is our family’s visits to Colonial Williamsburg and touring the various houses and shops on Duke of Gloucester Street. No visit was complete without a tour through the Governor’s Mansion and afterwards through the George Wythe House, situated along the green. In spring, the herb gardens scented the air and the buzzing of many bees could be heard as we passed by. To top it off, one year we also went on a ghost tour which involved going into some of the buildings at night and listening to stories of the long dead that still inhabited these houses. The tour we took ended up at the Wythe house which was gothically spooky at night.
I preface my blog post with such a reminiscence because my choice for subject this week is I am Murdered : George Wythe, Thomas Jefferson and the Killing that shocked a New Nation by Bruce Chadwick. I was familiar with the story that George Wythe had died in Richmond and that his grandnephew had been guilty of the murder because he was anxious to inherit his eighty year old uncle’s fortune. George Wythe Sweeney was undoubtedly guilty of this heinous crime, but for some reason, he was never charged. His uncle lived long enough to disinherit his nephew, so in the end, while the teen had his freedom, he did not receive the money he sought.
This book goes into exhaustive detail of the life and times of George Wythe who was a gifted lawyer, judge and teacher and signer of the Declaration of Independence. He is also responsible for many of Virginia’s founding documents such as the Religious Bill of Rights. His close friend and pupil was Thomas Jefferson who tried to emulate him in life and work. He was beloved in Williamsburg and later in Richmond. And his death from arsenical poison was mourned in the White House.
This book is not for the faint if heart as it goes into the details of autopsy in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, a history of arsenic as a means of murder, the judicial system both before and after the Revolution, doctoring in the colonial period and other topics. Further, it delves into the lives of not only George Wythe and Thomas Jefferson, but those of the defense attorneys of Sweeney, the doctors that performed the autopsy, and Lydia Broadnax, a freed slave who worked for Wythe, witnessed the murder, and was not allowed to testify at trial.
Those who like Virginia history with a bit of mystery and CSI added will love this book. You will find this book under my name in the staff picks section.
Enjoy!






